Bhuvan.Essays, notes and small websites
Notes · 474Page 13 of 16

Short things, kept in the open. A commonplace book, formerly rabbitholes.garden.

Links worth your time with a line on why, quotes, verse, half-thoughts and the occasional rant. Longer pieces live in writing. Follow along by RSS.

Note

Poor countries are not catching up with rich countries

Poor countries seem to have stopped catching up with rich countries: The original story of divergence then convergence remains the same, despite the scope for the revised data to alter results. For the three decades leading up to the empirical literature on economic growth, the gap between developed and developing…

Read the note →
Note

An unified theory of vibes

Kyla Scanlon is one of the most perceptive writers about the US economy and culture. Several years ago, she coined the term “vibecession” to describe the divergence between economic data and how people felt. In other words, after the pandemic, something weird started happening in the US. While economic data, despite the inflationary spike, was getting better, consumer sentiment was getting worse and worse.

Many people have proposed different theories as to why there’s a vibecession, and I’m utterly fascinated with the concept. For all its flaws, it’s a useful frame to think about many of the issues and trends that are shaping our lives. Anyways, here are a few recent posts on vibes.

Everyone is Gambling and No One is Happy.

Vibecession: Much More Than You Wanted To Know.

Theories of vibes.

I’ve been thinking about how much vibes can explain issues and sentiments in developing countries like India.

Note
Note

How to read more

How to read more? Just do it! I read somewhere that authors are voracious readers. I would imagine so. When I read, I also feel the urge to create something of my own. Likewise, I don’t think I’ve ever come across a writer who doesn’t read. Come to think of it, reading and writing are one and the same. Off the top of…

Read the note →
Note

Monkeys are really good at predicting electoral winners

This article made me laugh. Also a good example of how our behavior is shaped by deep-rooted behavioral patterns that have evolved over thousands of years under various selection pressures. This one made me laugh. Also a good example of how our behavior is shaped by deep-rooted behavioral patterns that have evolved…

Read the note →
Note

We’re are all unoriginal

Nothing is original. We’re are always copying and stealing from others.

Writing Down the Bones by Natalie Goldberg and Julia Cameron:

We always worry that we are copying someone else, that we don’t have our own style. Don’t worry. Writing is a communal act. Contrary to popular belief, a writer is not Prometheus alone on a hill full of fire. We are very arrogant to think we alone have a totally original mind. We are carried on the backs of all the writers who came before us. We live in the present with all the history, ideas, and soda pop of this time. It all gets mixed up in our writing. Writers are great lovers. They fall in love with other writers. That’s how they learn to write. (Location 1,281)

From Rob Henderson.

Note

How much knowledge has been lost

I was rewatching the tv show Vikings, and this part about lost knowledge stuck a chord: King Ecbert: Tell me honestly: What do you think of these works? Athelstan: I find them indescribably beautiful. King Ecbert: But they are clearly pagan! \[laughs\] King Ecbert: You are only a monk, Athelstan, and yet, somehow, I…

Read the note →
Note

Learn some philosophy

It might sound banal but I’m still amazed at how much good content is available for free on YouTube. Got example, here’s a list of curated channels about philosophy.

Note

Virtue cannot be known without knowing vice

True dis. “I cannot praise a fugitive and cloistered virtue, unexercised and unbreathed, that never sallies out and sees her adversary but slinks out of the race, where that immortal garland is to be run for, not without dust and heat. Assuredly we bring not innocence into the world, we bring impurity much rather; that…

Read the note →
Note

Charlie Munger on dealing with setbacks in life

Gemini summary: Here is a summary of the video based on the transcript. Video: How Charlie Munger Survive Life’s Hardest Moments... | Final Interview with CNBC 2023 Channel: YAPSS This video features a segment from Charlie Munger’s final interview with CNBC, where he discusses resilience, personal tragedy, and the…

Read the note →
Note

The future of global trade

This is just sad:

Both economists agree that growth is still possible, but the age of “hyperglobalisation” – with its extraordinary convergence of openness, technology, and trust – is unlikely to return.

“Growth miracles seem less likely because two of the key mechanisms – access to big, lucrative markets and willingness to share technology across borders – no longer seem to be here.” Goldberg

As global trade enters a new, more fragmented era, the challenge for policymakers will be to find fresh ways to generate dynamic gains – in a world where the rules, and the relationships, are shifting fast.

Note

Oral traditions in India

From: It would be wrong to apply Western theories of folk literature to India’s oral traditions, Kumar cautions readers. Local beliefs and worldviews seep into the songs and tales that evolve in any particular community. Moreover, in the telling of the tales and in the mode of singing as well, the local forms and…

Read the note →
Note

Ah, but is not this a glorious time for your deep inward fires?

From Autumn: From the Journal of Henry D. Thoreau:Thoreau) Nov. 13, 1851. To Fair Haven Hill. A cold and dark afternoon, the sun being behind clouds in the west. The landscape is barren of objects, the trees being leafless, and so little light in the sky for variety; such a day as will almost oblige a man to eat his…

Read the note →
Note

How many jobs can AI kill

A

I’m confident that AI is not going to wipe out anywhere close to 25M jobs on net over the next decade. If technological shocks caused net, long-run displacement, employment in the US would be 0. Instead, it’s among its highest peacetime age-adjusted levels. But… 1/2

…AI could absolutely drive gross displacement; think of automobiles displacing horse-related jobs even as they created new types of auto manufacturing & services jobs. That’s painful for workers, especially in the short-run & especially for workers in jobs more automatable.

Important to note however that even the amount of gross displacement from AI is highly uncertain; most of its use cases so far augment some tasks rather than replacing entire jobs.

Note

Take big shots

I’m fascinated with “advice” and what counts as good or bad advice. Alex Imas said something interesting and I think I agree:

This thread by Simon is spot on. Most advice is dumb—it’s too general to be useful—and I always tell my students I have no advice to give unless it’s very specific (eg run this analysis).
But “live over your skis” is good advice.

It means aim for more than what you think you can achieve.

The quoted tweet from Simon:

Going through my mental Rolodex from 25 years of academia. The people who do great things were ridiculous tryhards, particularly early on.
Reaching further than they had a right to. As if something in their souls knew. If lucky, tutors and friends indulged this ultra cringe.

Note

AGI will be business as usual?

What if this version of “business as usual” reality comes true. Seems like a good frame to have in your mental toolbox when thinking about the future path of AI. in a post-AGI world, people will simply get used to the fact that computers can solve cognitive problems quickly, and beat us in any cognitive domain, just…

Read the note →
Note

What to expect when expecting

This is the most intellectually honest opinion to have about AI.

Philippe Lemoine

I think that if progress in generative AI continues, which I’m pretty sure it will (it doesn’t even have to continue at the current pace as long as decreasing marginal returns don’t hit too hard), cultural products will become massively diversified.

One factor that limits the diversity of cultural products is that they tend to have high fixed costs, so you need a large enough audience for them to be profitable.

But if generative AI massively reduces the cost of production, which it almost certainly will, then there should be an explosion of tailor-made cultural products.

I think this has the potential to have significant effects on society, though it’s hard to say what they will be exactly, because it means that people will have less cultural references in common.

Note

Did we get evolution wrong?

Was watching this video and wanted to understand more so I asked Claude and Gemini: Denis Noble and Richard Dawkins represent fundamentally opposing perspectives on how evolution works, centering on what drives evolutionary change and how biological information flows. \\The Core Disagreement: Gene-Centrism vs. Systems…

Read the note →
Verse

Evil by Arthur Rimbauld

Ufff. What a poem. Each verse feels saturated with the bloody, neglected horrors of our own time — horrors I’m no doubt forcing into it, but can’t help seeing there

Couldn’t stop hearing the echoes of the present.

While loud the red-flecked mouths of cannons sing
And grapeshot whistles under empty sky;
While, red and green, before each preening King,
The massed battalions break, and thousands die;
While flowers bloom and sweet grass grows again,
In splendid sunshine, under summer heat,
And madness grinds a hundred thousand men
Into a steaming pile of rotting meat; …

A God smiles down through incense-laden air
At chalices and altars, gold, ornate,
And slowly dozes off to mumbled prayer;
But wakes when black-clad mothers, bowed with grief
And weeping, clink into His silver plate
The few coins in a knotted handkerchief.

By Arthur Rimbauld

Verse

Leviathan by George Oppen

I came across George Oppen in this article, and a random Google led me to this poem, and the only word that can succinctly capture my reaction is “dayum!”

Truth also is the pursuit of it:

Like happiness, and it will not stand.

Even the verse begins to eat away

In the acid. Pursuit, pursuit;

A wind moves a little,

Moving in a circle, very cold.

How shall we say?

In ordinary discourse—

We must talk now. I am no longer sure of the words,

The clockwork of the world. What is inexplicable

Is the ‘preponderance of objects.’ The sky lights

Daily with that predominance

And we have become the present.

We must talk now. Fear

Is fear. But we abandon one another.

George Oppen.

Note

AI as a research partner

Timothy Gowers on using AI:

🧵 Full thread: https://x.com/wtgowers/status/1984340182351634571

I crossed an interesting threshold yesterday — one I suspect many mathematicians are now crossing. In the middle of trying to prove a result, I found a statement that looked true and would be useful if it were. Instead of proving it myself, I asked GPT-5, and in 20 seconds it produced a proof using a lemma I hadn’t heard of. I’m confident I’d have got there eventually, but it would’ve taken me about an hour. It feels like we’ve entered a brief but wonderful era where our research is greatly sped up by AI — but AI still needs us.

— Timothy Gowers

Note

Human nature will never change

Amen!

Markets change.

Businesses change.

Technologies change.

Human nature is a CONSTANT.

Read Shakespeare to grok people…

— Josh Wolfe

Reminds me of something I’ve heard Jim O’Shaughnessy say often:

“At the centre of all market pricing are human beings. I joke the Four Horseman of the investment apocalypse are fear, greed, hope and ignorance, only one of which is not an emotion. Fear, greed and hope have wiped out more money than any market downturn. Because of all the foibles of human nature that are well documented by behavioural research – and now by neuroloigical research – people are always going to overshoot and undershoot when pricing securities. A review of financial markets all the way back to the South Sea company proves this out. As long as human nature doesn’t fundamentally change, we can continue to arbitrage the pricing inefficiencies it creates.”

“As long as human beings price securities, we’ve got something to arbitrage.”

Note

The guy who financed Johannes Gutenberg

Today in learning Johann Fust financed Gutenberg: Johann Fust (c. 1400–1466) was a pioneering 15th-century German printer, merchant, and financier who played a crucial, though controversial, role in the history of printing in Europe. He is most famous for his association with Johannes Gutenberg, the inventor of the…

Read the note →
Note

AI blind spot

This is an interesting take by Daniel Rock:

I don’t happen to believe AI is going to take away all of the jobs. But it is possibly a blindspot-generating issue that the people studying AI’s impacts mostly love their jobs

Note

Invention of modernity

Nice reflection on history: Some months later, I joined a book club. Run by Venkatesh Rao, this year’s edition focuses on a simple idea that goes a long way: Maybe grand historical paradigms like modernity and postmodernity are not suddenly emerging monoliths. Instead we might see them as “history machines” consisting…

Read the note →
Note

Post-cognitive world

Interesting take by Like Burgis. This is stuck in my mental craw for some reason: I would also now add a surprising element to my 2024 essay: as the cost of cognition approaches zero, that which is repeatable will be replaceable—and will indeed be replaced—by AI (a favorite saying of Palantir Co-Founder Stephen Cohen)…

Read the note →
Note

Can AI eliminate information advantages

Interesting article in the Economist on how AI can help customers being ripped off: The extent to which AI truly eliminates rip-off markets depends on two things. First, consumers need to know how to use AI properly. Mindlessly repeating advice from ChatGPT is less effective than using the bot as a learning tool that…

Read the note →